Defensible — The HR Decision Kit

Defensible · Culture Craft

Can you defend your last people decision?

Most HR decisions aren't challenged when they're made.
They're challenged later — when Legal asks questions, leadership reviews the file, an employee challenges the outcome, or AI involvement becomes relevant.

Defensible helps you document the reasoning, identify vulnerabilities, and create a decision record before scrutiny begins.

Get Defensible → View Sample ↓

Terminations Performance actions Promotions & non-promotions AI-influenced decisions

Defensible · Culture Craft

01 — 06

Can you defend your last
people decision?

Most HR decisions aren't wrong. They're reconstructed later — under pressure — by people who weren't in the room.

02 — 06

1What specifically triggered the decision?

2What evidence supports it?

03 — 06

Question 3

Did AI influence this
decision at any point?

Screening tools. Scoring systems. Recommendations. If it touched the process — it counts.

04 — 06

4What was the strongest alternative you considered?

5Could you explain this clearly to legal?

05 — 06

If any of these are unclear,
the decision is exposed.

That's where risk shows up.

06 — 06

Defensible fixes that.
Before you finalize.

A 7-step documentation tool that walks you through one decision — clearly, completely, and in a format that holds up when questioned.

Defensible — The HR Decision Kit

Document it before it matters.

$47

One-time · Instant download

Add to Cart →

The Risk

The problem isn't usually the decision.

Most HR decisions are never formally challenged. The ones that are often fail for a different reason: the reasoning wasn't documented.

Why this employee?

What evidence was used?

Was AI involved?

What alternatives were considered?

Was the decision consistent with precedent?

Who approved the final call?

By then, the reasoning lives in memory, emails, hallway conversations, and assumptions. Defensible creates the record before it disappears.

Can you explain this decision clearly in 60 seconds?

Would this hold if challenged by the employee?

Would you make the same decision again with the same inputs?

Function

What Defensible documents

Defensible is a single-decision documentation tool. You use it before you finalize a consequential HR call — termination, performance action, promotion, role change. It walks you through the decision systematically so that when someone asks "why did you do that?" you have an answer that holds.

Captures what triggered the decision and what outcome you're choosing — before you've committed to a direction

Documents what informed the decision: performance data, policy, precedent, AI involvement, and who was consulted

Surfaces the primary weakness in the decision before someone else finds it

Forces you to articulate your rationale and the strongest alternative you considered — and why you chose this path instead

Runs a pressure test: three questions that tell you whether the decision is ready to proceed

Produces a formal decision record written for someone who wasn't in the room

Deliverables

What you get

Decision Capture

Precisely what is being decided, who is affected, what triggered it, and the outcome you're choosing

Input Documentation

Performance data, policy, precedent, AI involvement checkbox, missing inputs, and full consultation log

Vulnerability Map

Where the decision breaks under review — bias risk, documentation gaps, consistency check

Rationale Statement

Why this decision holds, the strongest alternative considered, and why this path was stronger

Pressure Test Gate

Three questions — a No on any one stops the decision and routes you back to fix the gap

Formal Decision Record

The final document — date, owner, summary rationale — written as it would be read in a review

When to use it

Use this when

→

You are about to finalize a termination and need the reasoning documented before the conversation happens

→

A performance action is imminent and you want to surface any exposure before you commit

→

A promotion or non-promotion decision needs to be documented consistently with how similar decisions have been made

→

AI was involved in any part of the process and you need to document where and how before the decision is final

Design

Built for the decision in front of you right now.

Available as a fillable PDF and an interactive HTML tool

Covers termination, performance action, promotion, and role change

Includes an explicit AI involvement checkpoint

Pressure test gate stops you before you proceed with an exposed decision

Produces a formal record written for someone who wasn't in the room

Not a compliance system

"This is a thinking tool. It makes you articulate what you actually know — and surfaces what you don't — before it becomes a problem."

Get Defensible

Create the record before someone asks for it.

One decision. Documented completely. In a format that holds up when questioned. Includes both fillable PDF and interactive HTML versions.

$47

One-time purchase · Instant ZIP download · PDF + HTML included

Add to Cart → See the System Pack →

Need ongoing infrastructure, not just one decision? See the Decision System Pack ($127) →